By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Sky Witness NewsSky Witness News
  • Home
  • Europe
    EuropeShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    German airport drone-bomb: Could Russia be involved? – BBC
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    European Commission disburses another €1.71 billion to Ukraine for drones, ammunition and air defence systems – EU NEIGHBOURS east
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Video. Moment Ukrainian drones strike the Kerch Bridge linking Crimea to Russia – Euronews.com
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Doubling drone supplies and strengthening air defence: Ukraine outlines priorities to EU partners – Міністерство оборони України
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Moldovan president says Russian drone flew over capital – Reuters
    November 17, 2026
  • South America
    South AmericaShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Iranian air defences shoot down US-made LUCAS drone over Strait of Hormuz – India Today
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Drones are becoming organized crime’s weapon of choice in Latin America. Governments are struggling to keep up – CNN
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Iran's IRGC claims to have downed another US MQ-1 drone – Latest news from Azerbaijan
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Iran says it captured US drone south of Qeshm Island in Hormuz – Daily Times
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    IRGC Claims to Have Landed a U.S. Drone South of Qeshm – IranWire
    November 16, 2026
  • North America
    North AmericaShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    2 Russian oil refineries reportedly targeted in overnight drone attack on Krasnodar Krai – The Kyiv Independent
    November 18, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Ukraine hits Crimean bridge in record drone strike on Russia – The Spokesman-Review
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    USS Theodore Roosevelt Strike Group Joins Region as Iranian Drones Target Bahrain; Gulf Airspaces Open – Avi-Go
    November 17, 2026
    Old Town Spring storefronts in Texas, photographed in 2020; illustrative archive, not the drone delivery launch
    Uber Eats adds Zipline drone delivery in the Houston area
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Fire reported at major Russian petrochemical complex in Bashkortostan amid drone attack – The Kyiv Independent
    November 17, 2026
  • Africa
    AfricaShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Ethiopia and Nigeria Collaborate on African-Made Drones – Africa Defense Forum
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    News – US Army evaluates unmanned capabilities during live-fire demonstration in Germany – US Army Europe and Africa Command (.mil)
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Drones account for nearly three-quarters of Sudan war deaths this year, UN says – Reuters
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Drones Strike Ethiopia’s Capital as Country Severs Ties with Eritrea – WSJ
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Security Council LIVE: Sudan’s war spreads as drones and hunger take a deadly toll – UN News
    November 17, 2026
  • Asia
    AsiaShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    ASELSAN’s EJDERHA HPEM System neutralises 51 drones simultaneously – Asia Pacific Defence Reporter
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    What a US$20 million US drone hub won’t bring to the Philippines – South China Morning Post
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    How Pakistan’s Turkish drone order may push India to step up local production – South China Morning Post
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    "It's So Noisy!" Residents Fume as Drone Deliveries Fly Overhead Dozens of Times, Drawing Mixed Reactions – 아시아경제
    November 17, 2026
    Illustrative white quadcopter camera drone flying against a blue sky.
    Terra Drone solidifies South East Asia presence with establishment of new base in Malaysia – Terra Drone株式会社
    November 16, 2026
  • Global News
    Global NewsShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    GEO World News Headlines on GEO News: full details and when it's on – TVGuide.co.uk
    November 18, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Iran Attacks Kuwait and Bahrain, Further Escalating Fight Over Strait – WSJ
    November 18, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    WHO calls for safe and ethical AI for health – World Health Organization (WHO)
    November 18, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Putin says EU is losing industry, falling behind competition ahead of meeting with Trump, Xi – CNBC
    November 17, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Zelensky urges US and Musk to lift Starlink restrictions and be on 'right side of history' – BBC
    November 17, 2026
  • Talent Showcase
Reading: Israel-Gaza: What did the ICJ ruling really say?
Share
0

No products in the cart.

Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
Sky Witness NewsSky Witness News
0
  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase
  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Sky Witness News > Blog > Global News > Israel-Gaza: What did the ICJ ruling really say?
Global News

Israel-Gaza: What did the ICJ ruling really say?

Sky Witness News Editorial Team
Last updated: 2024/05/16 at 3:28 PM
By Sky Witness News Editorial Team 10 Min Read
Share
02111320 13b0 11ef B1b2 E35c72b37f73.jpg
SHARE
Image caption, Then-president of the International Court of Justice Joan Donoghue said the ruling had been misinterpreted

The UN’s top court has resumed hearings on a case brought by South Africa accusing Israel of genocide in the Gaza war and seeking an emergency halt to its offensive in Rafah.

Israel, which has called South Africa’s case “wholly unfounded” and “morally repugnant”, is due to respond on Friday.

The words of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) have been subject to intense scrutiny since South Africa brought its case and it’s centred around the use of the word “plausible” in the ruling.

In January, the ICJ delivered an interim judgement – and one key paragraph from the ruling drew the most attention: “In the Court’s view, the facts and circumstances… are sufficient to conclude that at least some of the rights claimed by South Africa and for which it is seeking protection are plausible.”

Article information

  • Author, Dominic Casciani
  • Role, Home and legal correspondent
  • Twitter, @BBCDomC
  • 1 hour ago

This was interpreted by many, including some legal commentators, to mean that the court had concluded that the claim that Israel was committing genocide in Gaza was “plausible”.

This interpretation spread quickly, appearing in UN press releases, statements from campaign groups and many media outlets, including the BBC.

In April, however, Joan Donoghue, the president of the ICJ at the time of that ruling, said in a BBC interview that this was not what the court had ruled.

Rather, she said, the purpose of the ruling was to declare that South Africa had a right to bring its case against Israel and that Palestinians had “plausible rights to protection from genocide” – rights which were at a real risk of irreparable damage.

Video caption, Former head of ICJ explains ruling on genocide case against Israel brought by South Africa

The judges had stressed they did not need to say for now whether a genocide had occurred but concluded that some of the acts South Africa complained about, if they were proven, could fall under the United Nations’ Convention on Genocide.

Let’s look at the background of the case and how the legal dispute unfolded.

The ICJ was set up to deal with disputes between the nations of the world relating to international law.

That means laws that are agreed between nations, such as the Genocide Convention, a key measure agreed after World War Two to try to prevent such mass slaughter again.

Last December, South Africa launched an attempt at the ICJ to prove that, in its view, Israel was committing genocide in relation to how it was perpetrating the war against Hamas in the Gaza Strip.

It alleged that the way Israel had prosecuted the war was “genocidal in nature” because, according to the South African case, there was an intention to “destroy Palestinians in Gaza”. Israel absolutely rejected these allegations, saying the entire case misrepresented what was happening on the ground.

South Africa would need to show the court clear and hard evidence of an alleged plan to commit genocide. Israel, for its part, would have a right to examine those claims one by one and argue that its actions, in a dreadful urban war, were legitimate self-defence against Hamas, which is designated as a terrorist group by dozens of countries. That full case could take years to prepare and argue.

So South Africa asked the ICJ judges to first issue “provisional measures”.

That’s the ICJ’s term for a court injunction – an order from a judge to freeze a situation, to prevent any harm being done, before a final court finding can be reached.

Image source, Getty Images

Image caption, South Africa has asked the court to order an immediate halt to Israel’s incursion into Rafah in Gaza

The court was asked to order Israel to take steps to “protect against further, severe and irreparable harm to the rights of the Palestinian people”.

Over two days lawyers for both countries argued over whether Palestinians in Gaza had rights that the court needs to protect.

The ruling, to which 17 judges contributed (with some of them disagreeing), came on 26 January.

“At this stage of the proceedings, the Court is not called upon to determine definitively whether the rights which South Africa wishes to see protected exist,” said the ICJ.

“It need only decide whether the rights claimed by South Africa, and for which it is seeking protection, are plausible.

“In the Court’s view, the facts and circumstances… are sufficient to conclude that at least some of the rights claimed by South Africa and for which it is seeking protection are plausible.”

Having decided that Palestinians in Gaza had plausible rights under the Genocide convention, it concluded that they were at real risk of irreparable damage – and Israel should take steps to prevent genocide from occurring while these critical issues remain in question.

The court did not rule whether Israel had committed genocide – but did its wording mean that it was convinced there was a risk of that happening? This is where the dispute over what the court actually meant then took off.

In April, some 600 British lawyers including four former Supreme Court justices, signed a letter to the UK Prime Minister, asking him to stop arms sales to Israel and referring to “a plausible risk of genocide”.

Image caption, The words of the International Court of Justice have been under intense scrutiny since the case began

That triggered a counter-letter from UK Lawyers For Israel (UKLFI). The 1,300-strong group said the ICJ had only ruled that Gaza Palestinians had a plausible right to be protected from genocide – in other words, that it had been dealing with a complex and somewhat abstract legal argument.

The dispute continued in more letters and interpretations.

Many in the first group described UKLFI’s interpretation as “empty wordplay”. The court, they argued, cannot have been solely concerned with an academic question – because the stakes were far higher than that.

And, of all places, the debate crystallised in legal sparring before a UK parliamentary committee, debating the question of arms exports to Israel.

Lord Sumption, a former UK Supreme Court justice, told the committee: “I think it is being suggested [in the UKLFI letter] that all that the ICJ was doing was accepting, as a matter of abstract law, that the inhabitants of Gaza had a right not to be subjected to genocide. I have to say that I regard that proposition as barely arguable.”

Not so, responded Natasha Hausdorff of UK Lawyers for Israel.

“I respectfully insist that reading a finding of plausible risk that Israel is committing genocide disregards the Court’s unambiguous statements,” she replied.

A day later, Joan Donoghue – now retired from the ICJ – appeared on the BBC’s HARDtalk programme and explicitly tried to end the debate by setting out what the court had done.

“It did not decide – and this is something where I’m correcting what’s often said in the media… that the claim of genocide was plausible,” said the judge.

“It did emphasise in the order that there was a risk of irreparable harm to the Palestinian right to be protected from genocide. But the shorthand that often appears, which is that there’s a plausible case of genocide, isn’t what the court decided.”

Whether there is any evidence of such terrible harm is a question the court is far from deciding.

You Might Also Like

GEO World News Headlines on GEO News: full details and when it's on – TVGuide.co.uk

Iran Attacks Kuwait and Bahrain, Further Escalating Fight Over Strait – WSJ

WHO calls for safe and ethical AI for health – World Health Organization (WHO)

Putin says EU is losing industry, falling behind competition ahead of meeting with Trump, Xi – CNBC

Zelensky urges US and Musk to lift Starlink restrictions and be on 'right side of history' – BBC

Sky Witness News Editorial Team May 16, 2024 May 16, 2024
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article 99ff28f7 104d 4854 Be6a 8d6cfacaa4e7.jpg Former Ireland international headlines Ulster departures as nine to leave province
Next Article Hero Gettyimages 1365666365.jpg Commercial drone deliveries are demonstrating continued momentum in 2023
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Text To Speech

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Pinterest Pin
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe
- Advertisement -
Ad image

Latest News

Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
GEO World News Headlines on GEO News: full details and when it's on – TVGuide.co.uk
Global News
Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
2 Russian oil refineries reportedly targeted in overnight drone attack on Krasnodar Krai – The Kyiv Independent
North America
Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
Iran Attacks Kuwait and Bahrain, Further Escalating Fight Over Strait – WSJ
Global News
Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
WHO calls for safe and ethical AI for health – World Health Organization (WHO)
Global News
//

Welcome to Sky Witness News, your premier source for comprehensive and unbiased news coverage spanning across Europe, South America, North America, Africa, and Asia.

//

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles instantly!

Copyright ©️ 2024 Sky Witness News | All rights reserved.
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer
Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest Drone related news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?