By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Sky Witness NewsSky Witness News
  • Home
  • Europe
    EuropeShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Airport Drone Sightings: Why Flights Keep Being Halted Across Europe – The Aviation Hub
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Unifly Joins EU Defence Project SPECTRE on Counter-Drone Systems – DroneXL
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    German attack drones pass live-fire tests, with first deliveries planned this year – Defense News
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Russia launches massive missile and drone attack on Ukraine, killing at least 8 – Scripps News
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Bulgarian PM summons Russian ambassador after ship sinks in Black Sea drone attack – BBC
    November 20, 2026
  • South America
    South AmericaShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Petty theft case exposes North Korean worker at key Russian drone facility – NK News
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Ecuadorian Fishermen Sue U.S. Government Over Drone Strike on Their Vessel – The Maritime Executive
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Petty theft case exposes North Korean worker at key Russian drone facility – NK News
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Iran’s Revolutionary Guard says it downed 2 US drones in Strait of Hormuz – Anadolu Ajansı
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Mysterious bomb-dropping drones sank their fishing boats, survivors say. Who was behind the attacks? – CNN
    November 19, 2026
  • North America
    North AmericaShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    AUVSI: Drone and AAM Operations Have Scaled, but Part 108 Standards, Security Framework and Public Acceptance Remain the Hurdles – Avi-Go
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    FAA Lists Three Drone-Only TFRs in Utah and California, Anchorage VIP TFR Thursday, White Sands Closures Through Friday – Avi-Go
    November 19, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    FCC adopts final rules opening 450 MHz band for drone links, allowing drone-detection radar at 24.45–24.65 GHz and updating 800 MHz in-flight broadband rules – Avi-Go
    November 19, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Drone footage shows progress on U.S. 301 bridge project over North Edisto River – The Times and Democrat
    November 19, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Trump nominates Centcom Deputy Lt. Gen. Patrick Frank to lead Northcom, NORAD – DefenseScoop
    November 19, 2026
  • Africa
    AfricaShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Morocco & U.S. Armies Test Anti-Drone Robots to Deliver Faster New Technology to Warfighter – The North Africa Post
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Drone sightings spark burglary fears in Khayelitsha – Scrolla.Africa
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Researchers envision a future where defibrillator drones help people experiencing cardiac arrest – Stuff South Africa
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Middle East’s largest economy vows stronger support for North African nation hosting 6 Russian airbases with fighter jets and drones – Business Insider Africa
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Russia’s Africa Corps deploys ZALA Lancet drones in Mali as air and drone strikes more than double and recorded strike deaths rise nearly 150%, analysis says – Business Insider Africa
    November 20, 2026
  • Asia
    AsiaShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Man United will not pursue legal action against drone operator who filmed training – CNA
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Airbus partners with Drone Forge to advance Flexrotor in Asia Pacific – Airbus
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    HOBBYWING Showcases Integrated UAV Propulsion & Industrial ESCs at DronTech Asia 2026 – Unmanned Systems Technology
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Horns and drones banned as Shenzhen hushes for Trump and APEC – The Japan Times
    November 19, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Malaysia’s military eyes gamers for South China Sea drone surveillance – South China Morning Post
    November 19, 2026
  • Global News
    Global NewsShow More
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Russian missiles land in Poland, as Europe held military drills nearby. NATO calls it a violation – AP News
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    'Historic moment': global media react to Trump-Putin-Xi talks – RTL Today
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    10 years on, Britain reopens the Brexit fight — this time embracing the E.U. – The Washington Post
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Former TNA World Champion Set To Become Free Agent On December 31 – Wrestling Headlines
    November 20, 2026
    Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
    Britain Announces Brexit Reset Deal at E.U. Summit: What to Know – The New York Times
    November 20, 2026
  • Talent Showcase
Reading: The 2023 Hugo Fraud and Where We Go From Here
Share
0

No products in the cart.

Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
Sky Witness NewsSky Witness News
0
  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase
  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Sky Witness News > Blog > Global News > The 2023 Hugo Fraud and Where We Go From Here
Global News

The 2023 Hugo Fraud and Where We Go From Here

Sky Witness News Editorial Team
Last updated: 2024/02/15 at 1:56 PM
By Sky Witness News Editorial Team 11 Min Read
Share
Whsjohns2.jpg
SHARE



Posted on February 15, 2024
  
Posted by John Scalzi   
 

There’s an investigative report out on the administration of the 2023 Hugo Awards, by Chris Barkley and Jason Sanford, and make no mistake about it, it is grim. The short version is that eligible people and works were kept off the Hugo ballot, not because the Chinese government or the Chinese principals of the Chengdu Worldcon overtly demanded it, but because American and Canadian Hugo administrators made the censorship decisions themselves, often on grounds that were (to put it politely) misinformed. People and works who should have been finalists were denied their rightful place on the ballot. A fraud was perpetrated by the Hugo administrators: on the Hugo Award voters, on the Chengdu Worldcon membership, and on the science fiction and fantasy community at large.

And as a final kick in the teeth, that fraud? Really fucking badly done. It’s a farce, as well as a fraud.

I would like to believe that this is a one-off failure of administration brought on by the circumstances of this year’s Worldcon location, but inasmuch as Dave McCarty, the principal mover of this fraud (and, for the record, someone who I’d considered a friend for more than a decade) was involved in Hugo administration for several other Worldcons, we at least have to check in again on those results. The good news here is that prior to the 2023 Worldcon, the data and stats for the nominations and voting on the awards were made immediately available after the award ceremony, and any discrepancies would have been found and hopefully addressed. We have the power of community examination and vetting for all of those results, and for correcting any problems while that year’s Worldcon was still in operation.

We didn’t have that in 2023. The data and stats were released as late as possible, far after the closure of the Chengdu Worldcon, which meant, due to the highly idiosyncratic nature of the Worldcon structure, there would have been no substantial way to address these discrepancies after the fact. It’s pretty clear to me now that this strategy of delay was intentional, not to address any difficulty in compiling the data, but to evade responsibility for censorship and for perpetrating a fraud. And that, also, is an act of fraud. Who was responsible for releasing the Hugo voting and nomination stats and data? Again: Dave McCarty.

It’s not only on Dave McCarty, to be clear. Everyone involved in the removal of legitimate finalists from their place on the ballot is implicated, and, at the very least, they should have nothing to do with the administration of the Hugo Awards moving forward. Their actions regarding this year’s Hugo Award administration are appalling, embarrassing and shameful. They abdicated their duty as administrators. So they should not be administrators ever again.

There should be apologies: To the people who were wrongfully removed from the ballot, and to the people who were winners and finalists in 2023. The former did not have their deserved and rightful opportunity be to finalists and to compete for the Hugo award; the latter effectively now have asterisks on their achievements. None of them bear any blame for this, of course, and none of their works were not deserving of a spotlight or an eventual award. They are all injured parties to a greater or lesser extent. But we all know what we know now. It’s difficult to feel good about winning, or being a finalist, in a year when you now know a fix was in. Hugo voters should be apologized to as well; they were obliged to vote on a compromised ballot.

That said: Who will give the apologies? The Chengdu Worldcon no longer functionally exists; the Glasgow Worldcon is a legally separate entity that bears no responsibility for the actions undertaken by the 2023 Hugo administrators. Dave McCarty has apologized for being a jerk for those who questioned his administration of the awards but not, importantly, for how he administered the awards themselves. By his words and actions, he apparently believes that he did nothing wrong here. It’s doubtful any apology is coming out of that quarter. Others involved have apologized, which is good. But again, at this point in time, it’s too late to do much about the 2023 Hugo Awards. They’re in the books.

The 2023 Hugo Awards were fraudulent. Now it’s the responsibility of World Science Fiction Society, who owns the trademarks on the Hugos and Worldcon, and all future Worldcons, starting with Glasgow this year and Seattle in 2025, to make sure that this fraud never happens again. WSFS in particular needs to grow the hell up and get some teeth, and become an organization with the actual ability to enforce a standard of accountability with regard to how their trademarks are used and administered on a yearly basis. Part of that must be a contractual agreement on the part of any potential Worldcon for transparency and openness when it comes to the Hugo Award nominations and voting — and a guarantee that any discrepancies, accidental or intentional, are addressed before the close of the Worldcon, if the current relationship between WSFS and the annual Worldcon continues, or by some other mechanism, if changes are made.

Given the actions of the 2023 Hugo administrators, there should also be a ban on the administrators censoring work for political reasons. If the government of wherever the Worldcon is that year demands censorship of the Hugo finalists, then make that government fucking do it. (And then resign in protest.) The administrators should not be willing accomplices in the act of censorship. It goes against everything the Hugos, and any serious literary award, should be about.

To the credit of the 2024 Worldcon in Glasgow, it has already committed to openness with regard to this year’s Hugo nomination process, and will share, when the finalist slate is announced, the information about what works might have been deemed ineligible and why (Update: It has also accepted the resignation of Kat Jones as Hugo administrator). I can’t imagine that the 2025 Worldcon in Seattle will do any different. These are good steps and the right steps to take, but they cannot be the only steps. Real and substantive structural change has to happen. This report shows why: Because if it is not made, then any other future Hugo administrators can do what these administrators here have done. We make rules in the aftermath of violation. To not do so invites future violation.

I’ll end on a personal note here. I made my first Hugo finalist list in 2006. It had a huge impact in my visibility in the science fiction and fantasy world and on the course of my career. The first time I won a Hugo Award, in 2008, I was delighted, but more importantly I felt the community of science fiction fans sharing my joy at holding that trophy. In 2012, I was the emcee for the Hugo Awards, and as gratifying as it is to win one, it is equally gratifying to give them away to writers and artists and editors and fans. My Hugos means something to me. They mean something to lives and careers of the people who win them. The Hugos mean something to the community.

People are always in a rush to declare the Hugos “over” or irrelevant, especially when people go out of their way to damage them or their reputation. We’ve seen it before in just the last decade, when bad actors tried to destroy the value of the award from the outside, out of petulance and spite; we’re seeing it now, when bad actors have diminished the value of the award from the inside, out of arrogance and incompetence. What keeps the Hugos relevant is the choice of people who love and value science fiction and fantasy to make it so. And that means making sure the Hugos are robust and resilient, and up to the times. Not just in who and what gets nominated and becomes a finalist, but in how they are administered, and how they move through the culture of science fiction and the world.

We’ve hit a very bad moment with the Hugos. What happens next decides whether this is a one-time event, or something that continues to diminish the Hugos as we move forward. I’m optimistic; this community has risen to the challenge before and met it. I think it’ll do so again. Not only because it has to — because it fucking well has to — but because it wants to. And when it does, the Hugo Awards will be better for it, and so will the community and genres it celebrates.

— JS

Like this:

Like Loading…

← Happy Valentine’s Day, Here’s kd lang With a Hugely Romantic Song

You Might Also Like

Russian missiles land in Poland, as Europe held military drills nearby. NATO calls it a violation – AP News

'Historic moment': global media react to Trump-Putin-Xi talks – RTL Today

10 years on, Britain reopens the Brexit fight — this time embracing the E.U. – The Washington Post

Former TNA World Champion Set To Become Free Agent On December 31 – Wrestling Headlines

Britain Announces Brexit Reset Deal at E.U. Summit: What to Know – The New York Times

Sky Witness News Editorial Team February 15, 2024 February 15, 2024
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article 16 February 1.jpg Delhi Chalo Farmer Protest, Japan 4th largest economy, Julian Assange’s extradition and Important Education News
Next Article Upimhjmxg5h2hbiupyttvbxugm.jpg European coalition to rush first-person-view drones to Ukraine
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Text To Speech

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Pinterest Pin
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe
- Advertisement -
Ad image

Latest News

Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
Russian missiles land in Poland, as Europe held military drills nearby. NATO calls it a violation – AP News
Global News
Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
'Historic moment': global media react to Trump-Putin-Xi talks – RTL Today
Global News
Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
Airport Drone Sightings: Why Flights Keep Being Halted Across Europe – The Aviation Hub
Europe
Sky Witness News - Photo unavailableSky Witness News - Photo unavailable
10 years on, Britain reopens the Brexit fight — this time embracing the E.U. – The Washington Post
Global News
//

Welcome to Sky Witness News, your premier source for comprehensive and unbiased news coverage spanning across Europe, South America, North America, Africa, and Asia.

//

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles instantly!

Copyright ©️ 2024 Sky Witness News | All rights reserved.
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer
Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest Drone related news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?