By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Sky Witness NewsSky Witness News
  • Home
  • Europe
    EuropeShow More
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Ukraine hits Crimea Bridge halting traffic on key crossing to Russia – The Independent
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Estonia moves to close Russian border after foiled ‘sabotage’ at drone maker – Brussels Signal
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Nokia to develop ISAC technology for US military drone detection project – Mobile Europe
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Estonia to close border with Russia after arson attack on local drone maker – Defense News
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Ukraine launches biggest drone attack on Russia since war began, defence ministry data shows – Reuters
    November 16, 2026
  • South America
    South AmericaShow More
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    IRGC Claims to Have Landed a U.S. Drone South of Qeshm – IranWire
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    IRGC Navy Says US MQM-170 Drone Captured Intact South of Qeshm Island – WANA News Agency
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Iran says it captured US drone south of Qeshm Island in Strait of Hormuz – Apa.az
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Iran’s IRGC Navy seizes 4th US MQM-170 drone intact – Mehr News Agency
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    South Korea's HD Hyundai and Anduril Launch New Unmanned Vessel Developed for U.S. Navy Market – Army Recognition
    November 15, 2026
  • North America
    North AmericaShow More
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Fire reported at major Russian petrochemical complex in Bashkortostan amid drone attack – The Kyiv Independent
    November 17, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Drone attack kills 1, injures 4 in Russia's Rostov Oblast, governor says – The Kyiv Independent
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Purdue Joins Indiana Drone Corridor Launch as State Opens FAA-Designated UAS Test Site – Avi-Go
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Civilian U.S. medics in Kuwait attack describe drone strike chaos, lack of preparation – CBS News
    November 16, 2026
    Illustrative archive photograph of Zipline delivery equipment displayed on a table at Open Sauce in California.
    Chipotle and Zipline demonstrate drone meal delivery at Austin golf course
    November 15, 2026
  • Africa
    AfricaShow More
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    The Civilian Cost of Ethiopia’s Drone War – Addis Insight
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Putin's secret recruitment network exposed as young African women lured to Russia to build drones to attack Ukraine – LBC
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Takeaways from an AP investigation of Russia recruiting Africans to make drones for use in Ukraine – AP News
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Ghana, DRC and other African countries feature in new report linking 50 African women to Russia's attack drone industry used to fight Ukraine – Business Insider Africa
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    African Women Recruited to Russian Drone Factories: Report – Yahoo
    November 16, 2026
  • Asia
    AsiaShow More
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Terra Drone solidifies South East Asia presence with establishment of new base in Malaysia – Terra Drone株式会社
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Ukraine Hits Kerch Bridge in 1,336-Drone Overnight Barrage – Daily Voice Of Asia
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Ukraine strikes bridge linking Russia to Crimea in 1,336-drone barrage – South China Morning Post
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Ukraine hits Russia's Crimea bridge in 1,300-drone barrage – CNA
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Drone ownership ban comes into force in Beijing over security concerns – The Japan Times
    November 15, 2026
  • Global News
    Global NewsShow More
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Two major Kyiv bridges hit in Russian attack, mayor says – BBC
    November 17, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    British women receive pardons for past abortion convictions – AP News
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Ousted President Is Moved From Comfort to Military Prison – Newser
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) – World Health Organization (WHO)
    November 16, 2026
    J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
    World leaders gather for Apec and Asean summits ahead of Trump-Xi-Putin meeting – live updates – The Guardian
    November 16, 2026
  • Talent Showcase
Reading: Tucker Carlson interview: Fact-checking Putin’s ‘nonsense’ history
Share
0

No products in the cart.

Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Font ResizerAa
Sky Witness NewsSky Witness News
0
  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase
  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Sky Witness News > Blog > Global News > Tucker Carlson interview: Fact-checking Putin’s ‘nonsense’ history
Global News

Tucker Carlson interview: Fact-checking Putin’s ‘nonsense’ history

Sky Witness News Editorial Team
Last updated: 2024/06/19 at 4:07 PM
By Sky Witness News Editorial Team 9 Min Read
Share
132605907 27c06ac2044771f045a161e5e4de5308d853a24d0 231 6000 33752000x1125.jpg
SHARE

9 February 2024

Image caption, Mr Putin began the interview by claiming that 862 was the year of the “establishment of the Russian state”

US talk show host Tucker Carlson’s interview with Russian President Vladimir Putin began with a rambling half-hour lecture on the history of Russia and Ukraine.

Mr Carlson, frequently appearing bemused, listened as Mr Putin expounded at length about the origins of Russian statehood in the ninth century, Ukraine as an artificial state and Polish collaboration with Hitler.

It is familiar ground for Mr Putin, who infamously penned a 5,000-word essay entitled “On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians” in 2021, which foreshadowed the intellectual justification the Kremlin offered for its invasion of Ukraine less than a year later.

Historians say the litany of claims made by Mr Putin are nonsense – representing nothing more than a selective abuse of history to justify the ongoing war in Ukraine.

Regardless of the historical realities, none of Putin’s assertions would form a legal justification for his invasion.

A state-centred narrative

Mr Putin began the interview by claiming that 862 was the year of the “establishment of the Russian state”. This was the year that Rurik, a Scandinavian prince, was invited to rule over the city of Novgorod, the capital of the Rus – the people who would eventually develop into today’s Russians.

Mr Putin contrasts what he claims is the unbroken tradition of Russian statehood dating back to the 9th Century with the modern “invention” of Ukraine – a country he insists was “created” as late as the 20th Century.

Image source, Getty Images

Image caption, An engraving showing Prince Rurik in 862

But Sergey Radchenko, a historian at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies, says the president’s claim is “a complete falsehood”.

“Vladimir Putin is trying to construct a narrative backwards, saying Russia as a state began its development in the 9th Century. You could equally say that Ukraine as a state began its development in the 9th Century, exactly with the same kind of evidence and documents.

“He’s trying to use certain historical facts to construct a state-centred narrative that would favour Russia as opposed to any alternative agglomerations.”

Ronald Suny, a professor at the University of Michigan, says the Rus was made up of “a bunch of bandits, who burned their own capital repeatedly”.

He adds that Mr Putin is repeating an “established mythology made up at certain points in the past by Muscovite tsars who trace their lineage back to Rurik.”

“This mythology was crystallised in Moscow to justify their imperial hold over Ukraine.”

A ‘special ethnic group’

Mr Putin told Tucker Carlson that by the 17th Century, when Poland came to rule over parts of present-day Ukraine, they introduced the idea that the population of those areas “was not exactly Russians. Because they lived on the fringe, they were Ukrainians.”

“Originally the word Ukrainian meant that the person was living on the outskirts of the state, along the fringes.”

But Anita Prazmowska, a professor emerita at the LSE, says that although a national consciousness emerged later among Ukrainians than other central European nations, there were Ukrainians during that period.

“[Vladimir Putin] is using a 20th Century concept of the state based on the protection of a defined nation, as something that goes back. It doesn’t.”

Mr Suny says that while it may be true that Russians, Ukrainians and Belarusians “came from the same stock … through time, they developed into different peoples.”

‘New Russia’

Mr Putin claims that areas in the south and east of Ukraine “had no historical connection with Ukraine whatsoever”. Conquered from the Ottoman Empire by the Russian Empress Catherine the Great in the 17th Century, the Russian president says that means these lands are in fact rightfully Russian. Mr Putin later refers to them using the 18th Century term “Novorossiya” – New Russia.

Mr Suny points out that the inhabitants of these lands when they were conquered by Russia were neither Russian nor Ukrainian, but Ottoman, Tatar or Cossacks – Slavic peasants who had fled to the frontiers.

Image source, Getty Images

Image caption, Catherine the Great conquered parts of present-day Ukraine

But claiming that these territories are in reality rightfully Russian serves Mr Putin’s interests, as they are precisely the areas that Russia is attempting to conquer from Ukraine during the now decade-long conflict with its neighbour.

So-called Novorossiya includes Crimea – illegally annexed from Ukraine in 2014. New Russia also covers areas around Kherson, Mariupol and Bakhmut, which Mr Putin declared part of Russia in 2022.

An ‘artificial state’

Mr Putin went on to claim that “Ukraine is an artificial state that was shaped at [Joseph] Stalin’s will,” arguing that Ukraine was created by the Soviet leadership in the 1920s and received lands to which it had no historical claim.

In a sense, he is correct, says Prof Radchenko. The Soviet leadership drew up the borders of Soviet republics “almost like the Western colonial powers drew up borders in Africa – kind of randomly.”

“But that does not mean that Ukrainians did not exist.”

More broadly, Mr Radchenko denies Mr Putin’s claims that Ukraine is not a real country because it was formed in its modern form in the 20th Century. “Any country is a fake country, in the sense that countries are created as a result of a historical process.”

“Russia was created as a result of decisions taken by the Russian tsars, such as the colonisation of Siberia, which came at the considerable expense of the local population.

“If Ukraine is a fake country, then so is Russia.”

‘Collaborating with Hitler’

Perhaps Mr Putin’s most inflammatory claim was regarding Poland. Mr Putin claimed that Poland – which was invaded by Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union in 1939 – “collaborated with Hitler”.

The Russian president told his interviewer that by refusing to cede an area of Poland called the Danzig Corridor to Hitler, Poland “went too far, pushing Hitler to start World War Two by attacking them”.

For Prof Prazmowska, President Putin’s interpretation of history is a flawed reading of the historical record. She says that while it is true that there were diplomatic contacts between Poland and the Nazis – the first treaty Hitler signed after coming to power was a non-aggression pact with Poland in 1934 – Mr Putin is conflating diplomatic outreach to a threatening neighbour with collaboration.

“The accusation that the Poles were collaborating is nonsense,” says Mrs Prazmowska.

“You can’t interpret these things as if this were collaboration with Nazi Germany, because it just so happened that the Soviet Union also signed treaties with Germany [at the same time].”

In September 1939, Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union invaded Poland according to the terms of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact signed between both states earlier that year.

You Might Also Like

Two major Kyiv bridges hit in Russian attack, mayor says – BBC

British women receive pardons for past abortion convictions – AP News

Ousted President Is Moved From Comfort to Military Prison – Newser

Middle East respiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV) – World Health Organization (WHO)

World leaders gather for Apec and Asean summits ahead of Trump-Xi-Putin meeting – live updates – The Guardian

Sky Witness News Editorial Team June 19, 2024 June 19, 2024
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Gettyimages 1273681288 Scaled.jpg Hezbollah threatens war against Cyprus if it helps Israel – POLITICO
Next Article 19putin Vietnam Explainer 01 Hpvw Facebookjumbo.jpg Why Is Putin Traveling to Vietnam?
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Text To Speech

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Pinterest Pin
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe
- Advertisement -
Ad image

Latest News

J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
Fire reported at major Russian petrochemical complex in Bashkortostan amid drone attack – The Kyiv Independent
North America
J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
Two major Kyiv bridges hit in Russian attack, mayor says – BBC
Global News
J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
Ukraine hits Crimea Bridge halting traffic on key crossing to Russia – The Independent
Europe
J6 Cofbogxhri9im864nl Ligxvsqp2aupskei7z0cnnfdvgumwuy20nuuhkreqyrpy4beeibucs0 W300 Rw.webp
British women receive pardons for past abortion convictions – AP News
Global News
//

Welcome to Sky Witness News, your premier source for comprehensive and unbiased news coverage spanning across Europe, South America, North America, Africa, and Asia.

//

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Europe
  • South America
  • North America
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Global News
  • Talent Showcase

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our latest articles instantly!

Copyright ©️ 2024 Sky Witness News | All rights reserved.
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer
Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest Drone related news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?